There's really nothing quite like Noah's Mill. It is a unique bourbon for many different reasons. Each bottling contains whiskey hand selected and blended from barrels ranging from 4 to 20 years old. These barrels all contain bourbons of an array of mash bills, meaning the content of the finished product is somewhat of a mystery. All of this careful selection and blending of mysterious old barrels clearly pays off when you experience the finished product. It is a bold whirlwind of rich, complex, unusual flavors one after another. Toffee, coffee, vanilla, raisins, and a blast of spice on the nose. Flavors of dark dried fruits like figs and raisins combine with a distinct dark chocolate, coffee note and a pecan nuttiness. Fresh ginger and dried orange peels liven things up a bit before the spices kick in. Needless to say, this is a very bold bourbon and not for the faint of heart.
91pts - Vinous
"Spice-accented aromas of dark berries and cherry take on a spicy nuance as the wine opens up. Bitter cherry, cassis and succulent herb flavors deepen and become sweeter on the back half, which is energized by a jolt of white pepper. Closes juicy, taut and long; sneaky tannins lend shape and firming grip."